7 Comments

Thanks Alex, so true. What a sad, sorry state we are in!! It is likely once again only fear which keeps us from taking appropriate steps! If only we'd remember the refrain of the song that was heard on the streets of London about 3-4 years ago :

"we are the 99%!"

Keep going, you write so eloquently, expressing thoughts I couldn't make clear!

Expand full comment
Oct 6·edited Oct 6

Thank you for all the research and time you spend on your excellent articles.

Regarding taxation, I think most of us are incurious and illiterate, largely owing to the complexity and opacity of taxation systems in most countries. Indeed, we have very little say in how the money is spent.

I, too, would like answers. I think wholesale and widespread incompetence and/or corruption may account for the missing billions or trillions. It's possible that if this missing money was accounted for, there would be a huge public outcry, so huge as to damage a government. Alex, I'll give your questions thought, but I think the system, in so-called democracies at least, is a great big swindle. Ministers and other officials go on public funded holidays, thinly disguised as meetings, in plush accommodation. Private aircraft are often used for these jolly occasions, in spite of net zero. They also get many freebies, don't they, Mr. Starmer and friends!

When it comes to trust, I have absolutely no trust in any government department or large corporate entity, including large charities. With your choir, being small, local, and hopefully transparent, it can be trusted. This applies to local charities in general if they're worth their salt.

Unfortunately I lack the courage to refuse to pay taxes.

Expand full comment

Thanks for this excellent piece, so clearly expressed. The historical factors are interesting, I had just accepted the inevitability of taxes and hadn't really thought about every way we are taxed, it's quite an astoundingly long list.

The second home tax in Wales is pretty damaging. It might free up homes but they are too expensive for local people generally. There are 40 properties on the market in our area of 1750 people. There are penalties if you can't sell in a time frame. If you rent them out you have all the issues associated with being a landlord, as all landlords are assumed to be unscrupulous. Selling off of council housing under Thatchers 'right to buy' scheme and not replacing it with anything remotely similar has been the biggest disaster on the housing front.

Thanks for raising my awareness.

There was some success getting the 'Poll Tax' changed due to the power of the people.

Expand full comment
author

The second home tax in Wales is an example of taxation with unintended consequences that has destructive effects rather than addressing the problem it was introduced to solve. It sounds much more like a kind of punishment for those who aren't doing things the way the authorities would like. As such, you could call it taxation-as-abuse! There are numerous examples of this now, and we'd all be much better at seeing them if we were more tax-literate.

Expand full comment

Tax was never destined to properly serve the collective-pot-for-shared-services ethos. To the extent that it does, it's accidental. This is because, as you point out, taxes were born in iniquity (war) and things have only got worse. Tax is also intimately linked to the banking / money creation fraud. The government raises debt to fund expenditure that goes to the corporatocracy - think £37bn for track and trace and God knows how many billions on 'vaccines'. The interest on that debt then goes to banks and is paid for by the taxpayer so it's a double whammy.

Tax is ultimately an efficient means of wealth transfer from the poor to the rich. And remember the rich, including multinational corporates, don't pay tax or, if they do, it's a token amount. Tax is the means by which we pay for our demise.

The tax strike would be a way forward...but united we stand and divided we fall. Even if you could get enough people on board, how do you tell an employer not to deduct PAYE? The bastards have put up a very effective barrier to a tax strike by collecting at source - essentially not giving you a choice. Which is exactly what you'd do if you knew that the money you were taking was not going to be used for the purpose taxpayers want it to be used.

Let's face it, 95% of tax really is just theft.

Expand full comment
author

You're right, and I chose not to include a bit about wealth transfer in the interests of keeping the piece reasonably short. It also occurs that tax-as-war-money is a form of protection money, along the lines of: "you pay us the costs of fighting our (the tribal leaders') enemies and we'll allow you to live on this land".

I don't know what the way forward is, but I think change will only come as part of change to the whole "democratic" system. And it will come, however painfully and however long it takes, because you can't keeping extracting, extracting from a population endlessly.

Expand full comment

You put alot of time into these pieces you do and its appreciated. Quite a journey for you these last four years. I have for many years now said to people why do they need to tax us if they can just create currency whenever needed. The fractional reserve fiat currency is a system is a ponzi scheme. creating debt to pay off debt. More Tax more war is unfortunately their way. Thanks for you research

Expand full comment